She has a dating profile on Plenty of Fish (that will probably be deleted but there’s plenty of screen-capped evidence). On the profile, she’s listed under her real location, Lancaster, PA and age, 26. This makes it rather easy to find the rest of her social profiles.
Under the username name, one can find her email address, photos of what appear to be her kids, and information about someone who appears to be her boyfriend (more on him later).
Schmucker is also on Twitter with the same username as she’s using on Plenty of Fish because, apparently, using the same incidentals on every social network is still a thing.
Also, looking at whom she’s following reveals several accounts with “Amish” and “AmishMafia” in the usernames although mostly bands and parody accounts.
With the same email/ username combination, she’s evidently also got profiles on MeetMe.com (deleted), Flixter.com (empty), MySpace.com (listed as a Single, Gemini by the name of Esther in Pennsylvania although the profile’s empty), Qik (empty), Formspring.me (only a few questions answered, none of which is interesting except her brother’s name), eBay since 2009 (although she doesn’t appear to have purchased anything), RecruitingBlogs.com, and Gravatar.
Back to Twitter, on that account, she seems to be harassing people who write things about her character.
For example, the account appears to have been opened December 29, 2012. On which date someone wrote, addressing no one, “If Esther is ‘hot’ by Amish standards, I really don’t want to see what an ugly girl looks like. #AmishMafia.” Schmucker’s account under the name “Samantha” replied “and that’s coming from you. Not even remotely attractive either.” Then, called out for not using a real profile photo, Schmucker’s retorted “only stating facts ;)”
Another user wrote, again addressing no one in particular: “Just to let all you Amish Mafia viewers know..this is really where Esther lives #UpTheRoadFromMe” with a link to a photo of a trailer. Schmucker replied anyway: “no she doesn’t. Those are her neighbors.”
In response to a private tweet from another person, that was no doubt critical, she continued: “it’s called “she’s not baptized in the amish community so they do what they want” unless you were amish then stfu.”
UPDATE 1/13/13: Reader Hilda in the comments says the private tweet at the end reads as follows: “Esther schmucker is the real esther from the fake show amish mafia and here is a pic of her drinking and partying with my friend, when the discovery channel starts admitting the show is complete fiction well stop spilling the beans on these ACTORS.”